New and future initiatives in crop genetic engineering. Debate the pros and cons of genetically modified gm crops. The conversation will revolve around the courage of independent scientists who value the importance of unbiased research and who have a firm understanding of the ethics of scientific research. Jan 26, 2012 ethical approaches to genetically modified crops january 26, 2012 by hawittmeyer in environmental ethics. Instead of making accurate statements on the safety of gmo foods, and demanding integrity and ethics in research, the scientific american and other professional scientific organizations seem to be advocating for gmo crops. Genetically modified crops sustainable living unilever. Ethical approaches to genetically modified crops sermons. So, small farmers are now completely dependent on large corporations for seeds and other necessities. It is strongly believed that animal trials should be used to evaluate the probable toxic effects of genetically modified foods 38, 40. Genetically modified crops that allow reductions in insecticides could have a positive effect in terms of environmental impact and farmerso production costs, although there has been insufficient time for ex postanalyses to be feasible. Ethical concerns in development, research and consumption. The ethics thinking toolkit provides additional support to help structure students thinking and decision making using ethical frameworks. Gary comstock, ethics and genetically modified foods.
The rainbow papaya variety is produced by introducing a protein from the prsv. Plant breeding research department, institute of crop and soil science. Developed at the university of hawaii, the genetically modified papaya is resistant to papaya ringspot virus prsv a plant virus spread predominantly by aphids. Jun 26, 2014 in this fourth instalment of gm in australia a series looking at the facts, ethics, regulations and research into genetically modified crops christopher mayes examines ethical issues. Byrne, colorado state university, professor, soil and crop sciences.
The seeds from gm crops are patented by the agribusinesses who produced them. Within these terms of reference, the council determines its own priorities and topics. If we think there are ethical dilemmas surrounding gm crops, dale muses, imagine the discussions concerning gm animals and, later, the impact of genetic knowledge on humans, where we all carry. To date, commercial gm crops have delivered benefits in crop production, but there are also a number of products in the pipeline which will make more direct contributions to food quality, environmental benefits, pharmaceutical production, and nonfood crops. Therefore, deontology, consequentialism, and virtue ethics were chosen as an underlying basis for our analysis. Gm crops, the use in the rest of the world increases annually. Vandana shiva, an indian environmental activist, takes a stand against gmos under the banner of indigenous, opensource farming and. May 11, 2011 biotechnology is providing us with a wide range of options for how we can use agricultural and commercial forestry lands.
Pdf an examination into the ethical acceptability of. The international library of environmental, agricultural and food ethics, vol 12. Preface when the working party began work in january 1998 there was little visible public anxiety about genetically modi. Gm crops grown in colorado include corn, alfalfa, sugar beet, soybeans, and canola. Furthermore, genetically modified organisms gmos, like all the new tech nologies. Considering the fast pace of new advances in production of genetically modified crops. Another major ethical concern surrounding gm foods is the disruption of natural biodiversity that is, aresultof crosspollination of genes from gm crops to natural foods, and the potential impact on ecosystems murnaghan 2012. Miriam schulman is the director of publications at the markkula center for applied ethics.
The ethical problems raised by genetically modified microorganisms gmms therefore mainly related to the impact they have on the earths biosphere. Biotechnology is providing us with a wide range of options for how we can use agricultural and commercial forestry lands. The use of genetically modified plants in agriculture gm crops is controversially discussed in academic publications. While science determines whether we can safely modify the genetic makeup of certain organisms, ethics asks whether we should. The use of genetically modified crops in developing countries a guide to the discussion paper there are many factors that contribute to poverty and hunger in developing countries, including war, political instability, lack of infrastructure and poor economic conditions. These questions guide student research in research on the nature of the debate regarding genetically modified crops.
Risks, benefits and moral obligation ben koole genetically modified gm crops on one side have been hailed as the solution to world hunger and have been criticized as environmentally dangerous, playing god and oillegitimately crossing species boundaries. People should be able to make their own decision whether or not to eat the food, based on the knowledge of if it is harmful to them or the environment. The use of genetically modified crops in developing countries summary and recommendations summary and recommendations introduction in may 1999, the nuffield council on bioethics published a report on genetically modified crops. Genetic modification has been widely used in agriculture for more than 20 years to make food crops more resistant to pests, more tolerant to herbicides and more resilient against diseases. In 2006 gm crops were grown on 102 million hectares in 22 different countries16. He first considers intrinsic objections to gm crops that allege that. Such approach is argued to guarantee that the gm crop is safe enough to be patented and commercially produced 38, 39. Apr 15, 2005 over 80 percent of the soybeans and 40 percent of the corn grown in the u.
Ethical concerns in development, research and consumption of. The first gm food produced was the flavr savr tomato in 1994, touted for its flavor and long shelf life. Vandana shiva, an indian environmental activist, takes a stand against gmos under the banner of indigenous, opensource farming and collective knowledge. This document complements ethics, morality and crop biotechnology written by dr roger straughan and the revd dr michael reiss, and published by bbsrc in 1996. Feb 28, 2018 we first illustrate how consequentialist and nonconsequentialist theories of ethics can be applied to the genetically modified organism debate, namely consequentialism, autonomyconsent ethics i. There are many scientists who argue that genetic engineering. Pdf ethics and genetically modified foods researchgate.
Important issues are whether the release of gm crops is bene. Ethics and agricultural biotechnology through the advancement of technology, scientists have been able to develop more precise and powerful tools to produce crops and animals with selected traits that aim to benefit farmers and consumers. Ethics and genetically modified foods springerlink. Gary comstock considers whether it is ethically justified to pursue genetically modified gm crops and foods. The ethics of gm food genetically modified food should a handful of people unbeknown to most have the right to start the contamination of australia with genetically modified crops and gm food when 90% of people have never heard of gm food. We do not claim that the use of gm crops alone will eliminate the need for. Bbsrc has published a leaflet why animals are used in biological research that outlines. Ethics, hunger, and the case for genetically modified gm crops. In 2004 it published a followup report, the use of genetically modified crops in developing countries. The use of gm foods and gm technology is surrounded by ethical concerns and situational. Diseases and allergies the mixing of genes from two organisms is also increasing the fear that new allergies could appear ethical concerns and gm foods. Genetically modified crops gmcs, gm crops, or biotech crops are plants used in agriculture, the dna of which has been modified using genetic engineering techniques. B all terms marked with an asterisk feature in the glossary at the end. Comstock then presents the positive case for gm crops that he endorses.
Developments in the genetic modification gm of foods and crops has resulted in a raft of controversies. Nov 22, 2002 if we think there are ethical dilemmas surrounding gm crops, dale muses, imagine the discussions concerning gm animals and, later, the impact of genetic knowledge on humans, where we all carry. From march 2008 the plan is to start contaminating our crops and food with gm. With the surge of gm foods, the notion of ethical eating has surfaced.
None of the best arguments for being against gm crops justify restrictive policies like those in place in the eu. The cultivation of genetically modified gm crops on millions of hectares of lands and their injection into our food chain is a huge global genetic experiment involving all living beings. The question of the uniqueness of genetically modified organisms. Ethical analysis of the use of genetically modified crops. There are also various concerns over the impact gm crops will have on other plant and animal species. Genetically modified food markkula center for applied ethics. The ethical concerns of gm crops include three main issues, allergiesdiseases, damage to the environment, and food webs and risks.
Genetically modified crops gm crops are plants used in agriculture, the dna of which has been modified using genetic engineering methods. See also an introduction to gmos, gmos environmental concerns, gmos health concerns, and gmos the future. Dec 28, 2015 while gm foods offer numerous health and agricultural benefits verma and others 2011, the public outlook on the consequences of genetic pollution and the ethical notions of genetic modification have given well. First, the current mechanism of distribution of genetically modified crops is designed in such a way that it only benefits the large scale farmers. Genetically modified gm crops on one side have been hailed as the solution to world. Are seeds that have been genetically modified a better alternative than pesticides. In this chapter, gary comstock considers whether it is ethically justified to pursue genetically modified gm crops and foods. More than half of the crops grown in the united states are genetically modified, including 70 percent of corn. Genetically modified foods are neither sacrosanct nor demonic, she says. Now there are two issues occur when genetically modified crops are launched in africa. Ethics and genetically modified foods gary comstock iowa state university ames, ia much of the food consumed in the united states is genetically modified gm, i. Similarly, pesticides nogall and mattch using other genetically improved species agrobacterium radiobacter are. Ethical issues raised by genetically modified microorganisms. In most cases, the aim is to introduce a new trait to the plant which does not occur naturally in the species.
They are part of a two week unit on the ethical considerations of gm crops, but can be modified to support much shorter discussions. Thompson and others published ethics, hunger, and the case for genetically modified gm crops find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Gm crops are the genetically modified crops of food so they dont rot before there sell by date. The panelists discuss a range of ethical issues related to questions of genetically modified organisms gmos and their environmental. Ethical approaches to genetically modified crops january 26, 2012 by hawittmeyer in environmental ethics. In 1996, gm crops were grown on less than 2 million hectares, nearly all in the usa where 1.
Genetically modified bacteria to produce the protein insulin, to produce biofuels from some gm bacteria, etc. Ethical compatibility of gm crops with intrinsic and extrinsic. The use of genetically modified crops in developing countries. He first considers intrinsic objections to gm crops that allege that the process of making gmos is objectionable in itself. For example, the analysis formed part of the background material for a recent statement by the danish council for ethics, arguing in favour of using gm crops to solve serious problems. In 1999 it published its first report on gm crops, genetically modified crops. In this paper,i examined the human action of having genetically modifying foods in kenya so as to determine if it is an. Ethics and genetically modified foods g ary c omstock iowa state university ames, ia much of the food consumed in the united states is genetically modified gm, i. Genetically modified foods massachusetts medical society.
The possibility that gm crops will form a large proportion of the plants. The ethical concerns about transgenic crops portland press. Ethical concerns in development, research and consumption of genetically engineered crops shayla nahar bhuiya 1 1. This article looks particularly at how it is used in crops, and examines the ethical concerns. The principal objections concern possible harm to human health, damage to the environment and unease about the unnatural status of the technology. The interdisciplinary journal of health, ethics, and policy 1.
Lastly, in agriculture, microbial strains are used to enhance the growth of plants and crop protection. Ethical issues involving the production, planting, and distribution of. Ethics of genetically modified crops by adrianna smyth tpt. This study provides a comprehensive overview of the moral reasoning on the use of gm crops expressed in academic publications from 1975 to 2008. Corn, soybeans, and cotton are the three largest acreage gm crops. While much of the earlier discussion had focused on first world fears of illdefined risks, the potential impact of the technology on the third world had been.
Ethical discourse on the use of genetically modified crops. There are many scientists who argue that genetic engineering in agriculture is the best way to solve many issues of pov. The voynich code the worlds most mysterious manuscript the secrets of nature duration. The introduction of genetically modified gm crops has become highly controversial in the uk and some other parts of the world.
One conclusion of the report was that genetically modified gm. Genetically modified crops nuffield council on bioethics. Genetically modified crops gm crops or biotech crops they are the plants used in agriculture, whose dna has been modified to induce a desired new trait. It is an internal ethical debate among scientists as to sciences relationship to the public good or corporate interests. Year 9 students used a range of ethical approaches to consider the acceptability of using modern genetic modification gm techniques to produce new or modified foods. In the united states genetically modified gm food has become a way of life. The scientific community is concerned about industry restrictions on testing of genetically modified seeds. In the same way as above, it has been necessary to develop genetically.
The other is the control of the worlds food supply by just a few agribusinesses. A large proportion of some of the worlds major agricultural food commodities, such as soy, maize and rapeseed are now grown as gm crops. Abstract the commercial application of genetically modified gm crops has been one of the major devel. The pros and cons of genetically modified gm crops issue. Worldwide, close to a billion acres are planted in gm crops, mostly corn and soy for animal consumption. In a metaanalysis, most of the studies showing genetically modified foods in a positive light were noted to have a conflict of interest. One is the claim that genetically engineered crops are the only way to feed the world. Diseases and allergies the mixing of genes from two organisms is also increasing the fear that new allergies could. Its perspective on gm crops has been guided by consideration of three main ethical principles. Also, there is concern that profit may be fueling the adoption of genetically modified crops. Important issues are whether the re this study provides a comprehensive overview of the moral reasoning on the use of gm crops expressed in academic publications from 1975 to 2008. This is an ethical question because we shouldnt feed people food if they do not know what it is and the issues surrounding it the risks. Genetically modified gm foods and ethical eating dizon. Risks and benefits of gmos markkula center for applied.
722 1188 495 37 1003 1013 865 564 62 1390 745 1554 39 783 473 1625 660 903 1625 829 812 1181 936 360 370 343 525 893 186 1240 1074 1284